While authorities worked urgently to locate the baby's family, investigators found the bodies of her four relatives just a few hours later in Tiptonville.
The accused teen and his dead siblings were homeschooled and raised under a strict, militaristic survivalist belief system, according to the documents.
Some internet trolls speculated that the Arkansas-born singer was a Mossad operative sent to entrap 45-year-old Patel, with at least one falsely claiming she was Jewish.
The bodies of the brave parents were found on the popular hiking trail just hours after the brutal assault, triggering an urgent manhunt for the suspect.
Police confirmed that Vogler and Hayes knew each other quite well and the attack stemmed from a personal dispute, which was not related to Vogler's position as a public official.
Prosecutors say the suspected abuse began when the girl was only six years old and continued until she was 11, around the time Powell and Bhagwagar ended their relationship.