According to investigators, McGlinn's role as a substitute teacher had nothing to do with the crime and she knew the victim as she was friends with his family members.
Makana Masacayan, 26, agreed a plea deal, under which the rape charge was dismissed and she was sentenced to three years of supervised probation instead.
Jim Bachmann, the school's former pastor, has now asserted that she was receiving private counseling sessions from Chad Scruggs, the institution's current pastor.