Florida Police Chief Fired After Asking 'Which One is Blacker?' When Promoting Officers in Diversity Push

The city of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, fired its police chief last week over accusations that he unfairly focused on minorities when hiring and promoting people.

Larry Scirotto, who was sworn-in as police chief in mid-August, and the city had hired a law firm by November to investigate complaints of discrimination before he was fired on Thursday, according to a copy of the law firm's report obtained by CNN.

'That Wall is Too White'

Larry Scirotto
Larry Scirotto Twitter

The investigation concluded that during his time as police chief, Scirotto implemented an approach to hiring and promotion that was unfairly focused on minority candidates.

The report said Scirotto, who is of a mixed-race background, once pointed to a conference room wall displaying photos of the department's command staff and stated, "that wall is too white," and "I'm gonna change that."

In one example in the report, Scirotto is alleged to have overlooked a White man with 20 years tenure with the department, and instead narrowed the choice between two men of color, and asked, "which one is blacker."

Scirotto Says Investigation Based on 'Hearsay, Promotions Were Based on Merit

Scirotto said the investigation was "built on hearsay," and lacked testimony, transcript and audio. He told CNN he promoted 15 people from August to November, and of that group, six were ethnic or gender minorities selected for promotions based on their merit.

"None of them were promoted because they were in a protected class," he said. "They were promoted because they were the best candidates."

Scirotto said he has obtained legal counsel and is planning on filing a wrongful termination lawsuit against the city. "If promoting diversity is the hill I'm going to die on, I will sleep well tonight," he said. "I won't allow them to tarnish my reputation. I won't allow them to tarnish the work that I've done in the 24 years I've been in this profession."

When asked about his approach to promotions, Scirotto told investigators he was going to "consider diversity at every opportunity," and he had to be "intentional" in his decision-making process.

Scirotto denied asking which candidate was "blacker" when deciding on the promotion, but admitted to making comments about the wall being "too white," because he felt it was not reflective of the community, according to the report.

"He said the context of the comment is built around 'how do I convince the community that we are an inclusive and diverse organization if this wall is so white?'" the report said.

"The bottom row had several white males and one white female. And we're talking in conversation as it relates to our community and the expectation of a diverse and inclusive organization. And how do I purport we have that when the entire bottom row are white men?" Scirotto told WFOR.

City Announced Scirotto's Termination on March 3

In total, 21 witnesses, gave a consistent narrative to investigators about Scirotto's hiring and promotion practices, the report reads. The investigation also concluded "almost every witness was dissatisfied," with Scirotto's approach to promotions, and "most believed that Chief Scirotto made clear his intention to promote based on race, gender or sexual orientation."

The city ultimately decided to cut ties with Scirotto, who did not have a contract with the city and will not be receiving a severance, city spokesperson Stephen Gollan told CNN.

"Following a thorough and extensive investigation of employee complaints at the Fort Lauderdale Police Department, City Manager Chris Lagerbloom, has determined that it is in the City's best interest to separate employment with Larry Scirotto," the city said in a statement dated March 3.

The city's police department is now under the leadership of Acting Chief Luis Alvarez, the city said, and the selection process for a new chief is underway.