NYC Mayoral Primary Thrown into Chaos after Board of Elections Mistakenly Counts 135,000 Test Ballots as Real Votes

The glaring discrepancy was detected after new numbers released showed Eric Adams's lead in the first set of ranked-choice voting results had narrowed down over Kathryn Garcia.

John McAfee Dies in Spanish Prison

John McAfee Dies in Spanish Prison

The campaign to become New York's next mayor was thrown into another chaos on Tuesday night after election officials admitted of mistakenly counting 135,000 test votes as real ones. The test votes had reportedly not been cleared from the computers and got counted as real votes that could bring in a twist into the entire results.

The massive blunder was discovered after new numbers were released wherein mayoral election frontrunner Eric Adams's lead in the first set of tabulated ranked-choice voting results had narrowed down over rival Kathryn Garcia. Former Sanitation Commissioner Kathryn Garcia, in this preliminary count, had nearly closed the gap, giving Adams a two-point lead.

Glaring Discrepancy

Eric Adams
Eric Adams YouTube Grab

After counting 11 rounds of ranked-choice votes Adams, a former police officer and Brooklyn borough president, was announced to be leading former Garcia 51.1 percent to 48.9 percent. The difference was 15,908 votes, without counting absentee ballots, the officials said.

Going by the number of total votes, preliminary results released earlier on Tuesday in the day showed a total of 941,832 ballots cast for mayor, an increase of more than 140,000 from the 799,827 that were counted on June 22, the day of the primary.

However, hours after announcing the results and following questions from the Adams campaign and others, the board backtracked and acknowledged a "discrepancy" in the counting process. The data of the released results was subsequently removed from the website.

Later in the day, the board acknowledged that it had mistakenly included 135,000 test vote records in the initial tally. "The Board apologizes for the error and has taken immediate measures to ensure the most accurate up to date results are reported."

Saved in Time

Kathryn Garcia
Kathryn Garcia YouTube Grab

When the board ran the program, it counted "both test and election night results, producing approximately 135,000 additional records," the statement said. The ranked-choice numbers, it said, would be tabulated again.

The glaring discrepancy at first went unnoticed and could have changed the entire result had Adams' campaign not flagged it on time. "The vote total just released by the Board of Elections is 100,000-plus more than the total announced on election night, raising serious questions," an Adams spokesman said.

"We have asked the Board of Elections to explain such a massive increase and other irregularities before we comment on the ranked-choice voting projection."

Ranked Choice Voting_Round 11
The initial Ranked Choice Voting: Round 11 results that were later removed from the website New York City Board of Elections

In response, the BOE scrubbed all the results from its website, replacing them with a message saying, "Unofficial Rank Choice ­Results Starting on June 30." Even then, many are now questioning why the agency even released the preliminary results.

The mess amounted to a realization of many New Yorkers' well-founded worries over the board's capacity to competently manage the ranked-choice system, which is making its citywide debut.

They said on Tuesday afternoon 941,832 votes have been tallied and 124,000 absentee ballots remain to be counted. The first absentee ballots results are not expected to be tallied until July 6.

Adams' campaign later appreciated the agency for acknowledging its mistake that could have been a costly fair has it not been detected. Adams in a statement said he and his team "appreciate the Board's transparency and acknowledgment of their error."

"Today's mistake by the Board of Elections was unfortunate. It is critical that New Yorkers are confident in their electoral system, especially as we rank votes in a citywide election for the first time," Adams said.